Johnny Depp's Ebenezer Opens to 52% on Rotten Tomatoes
Ti West's gothic Christmas Carol retelling lands at 52% on Rotten Tomatoes and 48 on Metacritic, with critics split on Depp's Scrooge and the film's purpose.

On this page
Key takeaways
- Ebenezer, Ti West's gothic retelling of A Christmas Carol, opens in US theaters on 13 November through Paramount.
- Rotten Tomatoes showed 52% and Metacritic 48 in snapshots on 12 November, putting the film in mixed-to-negative territory with critics.
- Box-office tracking pointed to a roughly $23 million opening weekend, against a reported production budget of about $38 million.
- Johnny Depp took a reported $5 million upfront, well below his usual fee, in his first major studio lead in nearly a decade.
- The film had already opened in France, where audience scores were reported as strong, a reminder that critic and audience reactions can diverge.
Johnny Depp's return to a major studio lead arrives with a split verdict. Ti West's Ebenezer, a gothic retelling of A Christmas Carol, opens in US theaters on 13 November with a 52% score on Rotten Tomatoes and a 48 on Metacritic, according to snapshots published by World of Reel on 12 November.
Related reading: Nocturne Opens at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, Then Slips to 83% · The Greatest Opens at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, With Ali as a Young Man.
The numbers are not a disaster for a film this size. They are not an endorsement either. The reviews cluster around a simple judgment: Depp is good, the film looks expensive, and the story does not justify another version. Several critics said the same thing in different words, which is usually a sign that the problem is the material rather than the execution.
What the critics liked
The positive notices focused on Depp and on West's visual style. The film is a PG-13 period piece with horror-adjacent imagery, snow, gaslight and a Scrooge who looks genuinely haunted. Critics who enjoyed it described it as a sincere, atmospheric take rather than a campy one.
"Ti West brings a lovely gothic visual style which helps freshen an otherwise standard take," Critics Choice member Clarence Moye wrote, according to Variety. "And of course Depp is great, standing with George C. Scott as the best of the modern Scrooges."
Tom Chatalbash of FilmSpeak called it a "wickedly fun holiday treat and strong comeback vehicle for its star," praising Depp for balancing "the goofy charm and emotional gravitas that has been sorely missed." The Hollywood Reporter's first-reactions roundup included a critic who called it hauntingly gothic and possibly the most faithful and creepiest version of the Dickens story.
Those are first reactions, not full reviews, and they tend to be kinder than the final tally. The Rotten Tomatoes score suggests the enthusiasm did not hold across the wider critic pool.
What the critics did not
The negative reviews made a consistent case: the film is well made and unnecessary. Scott Mendelson, writing on his Substack, called it "a cinematic lump of coal" and "a frustrating exercise in mediocrity." He praised the production design and Depp's performance but said the story had no added value, no new setting and no reason to exist beyond the star's comeback.
"Technically well made and Johnny Depp certainly looks and acts the part but the film commits 2 sins of being forgettable and just boring, especially if you've seen a Christmas carol before," critic Robert Ortiz wrote, according to Variety. Another critic, MaryAnn Johanson, summed it up in two words: "Utterly superfluous."
The "why does this exist" question is hard to escape. World of Reel noted that one outlet has counted around 272 adaptations of A Christmas Carol. West, who built his reputation on the X trilogy and Pearl, is working well outside his usual register. The film's defenders say that is the point. Its detractors say the novelty is thin.
Critics and audiences may not agree
The Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic scores are critic measures. There was no verified audience score for the US release at the time of writing, because the film had not opened. In France, where it opened earlier, World of Reel reported that audience scores were excellent. Depp's fans are a distinct audience from the critics reviewing a Christmas movie.
The business case
Paramount does not need Ebenezer to be a critical hit. The film reportedly cost about $38 million, according to IndieWire, with other reports putting the budget at $35 million to $40 million. Depp took a reported $5 million upfront instead of his usual $20 million, according to World of Reel, a pay cut that lowers the studio's risk and signals his interest in rebuilding a mainstream career.
Tracking pointed to a roughly $23 million opening weekend. If that holds, the film would recoup a large share of its budget in North America and would have the holiday season to leg out. Christmas films can run for weeks, and a PG-13 Scrooge story has a natural audience that does not read Rotten Tomatoes.
The marketing has leaned hard on Depp. Paramount put him in character for ads, staged an intimate preview screening and kept the campaign focused on the performance rather than the actor's personal history. IndieWire reported that the review embargo lifted on 12 November, hours before public screenings began, which is often a sign that a studio expects weak reviews.
That strategy can work. A star-driven holiday film with a modest budget does not need a 90% score. It needs enough screens, enough awareness and enough goodwill from Depp's fans. The early French audience reaction suggests that goodwill exists.
The comeback calculation
Ebenezer is Depp's first major studio lead in nearly a decade, and the campaign around it has been built as a reintroduction rather than a comeback tour. Paramount kept the press push focused on the performance. Depp did in-character advertising, gave few interviews and let the film's gothic imagery carry the message. IndieWire described the approach as emphasizing "his big performance over his personality."
The strategy is designed around a simple fact: the people who will buy a ticket to see Depp as Scrooge are not the people who read reviews. They are the audience that grew up with him in Pirates of the Caribbean and Edward Scissorhands, and they have been waiting for a reason to see him on a big screen again. A PG-13 Christmas film is a safer bet for that audience than a dark drama or a franchise reboot.
The pay cut fits the same logic. A $5 million fee instead of his usual $20 million lowers the studio's exposure and signals that Depp is willing to share the risk. If the film works, it gives him a commercial hit and a credible path back to bigger projects. World of Reel reported that Disney is already in talks about another Pirates film, though that is a report, not a confirmed deal.
For West, the calculation is different. He built his reputation on low-budget horror and on the X trilogy, and Ebenezer is his first studio film at this scale. A mixed critical reception will not hurt him much if the film makes money. A flop would make it harder for him to get another $38 million budget outside the horror lane. The reviews suggest he delivered a polished, atmospheric film. The box office will decide whether that is enough.
How the reviews break down
The Rotten Tomatoes split is not a simple positive-negative divide. The positive reviews tend to praise the craft and the lead performance while admitting the story is familiar. The negative reviews tend to concede the craft and the performance while arguing that familiarity is the problem. Almost nobody says the film is badly made. Almost everybody says it is unnecessary.
That is a difficult verdict for a studio to market. "It looks great and Depp is good, but you have seen this story before" is not a pull quote. The campaign has therefore leaned on the performance and the holiday mood, not on the critical response. The first-reaction quotes, which were warmer than the final reviews, did the heavy lifting in the trailers and social posts.
The audience score, once it exists, will be more useful than the Tomatometer. Christmas films often play better with audiences than with critics, and Depp's fan base is motivated. If the verified audience score lands well above 52%, Paramount can argue that the critics missed the point. If it lands in the same range, the film will have to rely on holiday tradition rather than enthusiasm.
There is also the international picture. The film opened in France before the US, and World of Reel reported that audience scores there were excellent. International markets have been important for star-driven films that underperform domestically, and Depp remains a bigger draw in some territories than in the United States. A strong overseas run could turn a modest domestic opening into a profitable release.
Scores are snapshots
The 52% and 48 figures were live snapshots on 12 November, before the US opening. Rotten Tomatoes scores move as more reviews arrive, and Metacritic can change too. The $23 million opening is tracking, not a result. The $38 million budget is IndieWire's figure; other outlets have reported $35 million or $40 million. Depp's $5 million fee and the reported Pirates of the Caribbean talks come from World of Reel, not from Paramount.
What happens next
The opening weekend will answer the commercial question. The critical question is already settled: this is a mixed review film with a strong central performance and a familiar story. Whether that becomes a holiday perennial or a one-weekend curiosity depends on word of mouth, not on the Tomatometer.
For Depp, the film is a test of whether a major studio will keep betting on him. For West, it is a detour from horror that may or may not lead to bigger studio work. For Paramount, it is a low-cost bet on a star and a season. None of those bets requires the critics to be wrong. They only require enough people to buy a ticket.
Tags
Frequently asked questions
- What is Ebenezer about?
- It is a darker retelling of Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol. Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge, who is visited by three spirits on Christmas Eve and forced to confront his past, present and future.
- When does Ebenezer come out?
- Paramount released the film in US theaters on 13 November 2026. It had already opened in some international markets, including France, before the US date.
- How are the reviews for Ebenezer?
- Mixed. Rotten Tomatoes showed 52% and Metacritic 48 on 12 November. Critics generally praised Depp's performance and Ti West's gothic visuals, but many said the retelling added little to a story that has been adapted many times.
- Will there be a sequel?
- No sequel has been announced. Paramount's hopes are focused on holiday legs and international grosses rather than a franchise.








