James Gray's Paper Tiger Opens to 85% as Neon Tests the Adult Crime Drama
Paper Tiger, James Gray's 1986 New York crime drama with Adam Driver and Scarlett Johansson, opened in limited release on 13 November 2026 to strong reviews.

On this page
Key takeaways
- Paper Tiger opened in limited U.S. release on 13 November 2026 and expands nationwide on 20 November.
- Rotten Tomatoes showed 85% from 114 reviews and Metacritic 81 from 32 critics on 14 November, both strong scores.
- The New York Times named it a critic's pick, while Variety called it a mixture of the grandiose and the implausible.
- James Gray's film stars Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller as a Jewish family drawn into the Russian mob in 1986 Queens.
- The film cost about $15 million and won Gotham Award nominations for Best Feature and for Adam Driver's supporting performance.
James Gray's Paper Tiger opened in limited U.S. release on 13 November 2026 to some of the best reviews of his career. Rotten Tomatoes showed 85% from 114 critics' reviews on 14 November, with an average rating of 7.0 out of 10. Metacritic showed 81 from 32 critics, a score that puts it at the top of Gray's filmography on that site.
Related reading: Nocturne Opens at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, Then Slips to 83% · The Greatest Opens at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, With Ali as a Young Man.
The film stars Adam Driver as Gary Pearl, a former police officer who returns to his family in Queens with a business proposition. Miles Teller plays his younger brother Irwin, an engineer with a wife, two sons and a mortgage. Scarlett Johansson plays Hester, Irwin's wife. The setting is 1986, and the proposition pulls the family into the Russian mob, according to the film's published synopsis.
Neon is releasing the film in limited theaters before expanding nationwide on 20 November. That platform strategy is standard for an adult drama with awards ambitions. It lets the studio build word of mouth in New York and Los Angeles before spending on a wide campaign, and it gives critics time to review before the film reaches most of the country. The film arrives after Ebenezer and How to Rob a Bank opened the previous week, in a season that has room for serious drama but little patience for a slow start.
What the reviews say
The strongest notices focus on the performances. Time's Stephanie Zacharek called the film "old school in the best way" and singled out Johansson's work as "superb." IndieWire's David Ehrlich gave it an A and described Driver's performance as a career best, praising a range that stretches across "flash, menace, and pure sincerity." The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney wrote that Gray and his cast are "in blazing form and full command," and said Johansson "has never been better."
The New York Times made it a critic's pick, with a review published on 12 November that describes a "richly textured, immediately convincing world." The praise is not unanimous. Variety's Owen Gleiberman called it a "mouthy, close-knit Jewish domestic psychodrama" and argued that Gray's direction turns it into a "mixture of the grandiose and the implausible." That split is typical of Gray's reception. Critics who value his control and his classical style rank him highly. Critics who want more plot momentum find his films slow.
The disagreement is also about tone. Paper Tiger is a crime drama, but the crime is not the point. The film spends its time on family dinners, cramped apartments and the small humiliations of a man who wants more than his brother's life. The Russian mob arrives as a consequence of that wanting, not as the engine of the story. Audiences who expect a thriller may find the pacing deliberate. Audiences who want a character study will find one.
Scores are live snapshots and can move as more reviews arrive. Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic use different samples and weighting, so the two numbers are not directly comparable.
The family story behind the film
Gray has described Paper Tiger as a personal project. It began as an idea for a follow-up to Armageddon Time, his 2022 memoir of growing up in Queens. In interviews, he said the new film would look at his parents' generation and the period when his father achieved financial success and then lost it to legal trouble.
The finished film keeps that family focus. Gary is the prodigal brother who left, made money and came back with a scheme. Irwin is the responsible brother who stayed, married and built a modest life. Hester is the person who sees the cost of Gary's proposal before the brothers do. The mob is a force that exploits the gap between the two men, not a separate villain.
Gray shot the film on 35mm with cinematographer Joaquín Baca-Asay, who also shot We Own the Night and Two Lovers. The choice is deliberate. Paper Tiger looks like a film from the period it depicts, with warm streetlights, dark interiors and a grain that digital cameras would smooth away. That texture is part of the appeal for critics who have praised the film's craft.
The budget was about $15 million, according to Gray. That is small for a film with three movie stars, and it explains the limited release strategy. Neon does not need a blockbuster opening to make the film profitable. It needs a long run, strong reviews and awards attention.
The business of a platform release
A limited opening is a bet on word of mouth. The film plays in a small number of theaters, usually in New York and Los Angeles, where critics and awards voters live. If the reviews are good and the screenings sell out, the studio expands. If the reviews are weak, the studio can limit its losses.
Paper Tiger's reviews are strong enough to support an expansion. The 85% score is well above the 60% threshold that Rotten Tomatoes uses for a "fresh" rating, and the 81 Metascore is in the "universal acclaim" band. The film also has a clear audience: adults who want a serious drama with recognizable stars. That audience has been underserved by a release calendar dominated by franchise films.
The wide expansion on 20 November will test whether the reviews translate into ticket sales. The weekend before Thanksgiving is crowded. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens on 20 November, and I Play Rocky opens the same day. Paper Tiger will be the smallest of the three, and it will need to hold screens against bigger marketing budgets.
Neon has a track record with this kind of release. The studio has turned festival acquisitions into awards contenders and profitable theatrical runs. It knows how to campaign for a film that critics like but that does not have a built-in franchise audience. Paper Tiger fits that model.
Awards season
The film premiered in competition at the Cannes Film Festival on 16 May 2026 and received a 10-minute standing ovation, according to Deadline. It opened the New York Film Festival in the autumn. Those are the kind of placements that signal awards intent.
The Gotham Awards, which focus on independent film, nominated Paper Tiger for Best Feature and for Adam Driver's supporting performance. The Gothams are not a predictor of the Oscars, but they are an early marker of industry enthusiasm. The film is also entered at the Gijón International Film Festival, where its Albar Award status was pending as of 13 November.
The Oscar race is harder to read. A spring Cannes premiere can help a film stay in the conversation, but it can also exhaust its momentum before voters focus in December. Neon will need to keep the film visible through the autumn festivals and the critics' awards. The strong reviews give it a foundation. The box office will determine how much the studio can spend.
Gray's reputation helps. He is a critics' director with a loyal following and a filmography that includes Little Odessa, The Yards, We Own the Night, Two Lovers, The Immigrant, The Lost City of Z, Ad Astra and Armageddon Time. He has never won a competitive Oscar, and Paper Tiger is being described as one of his most accessible films. That combination is attractive to voters who want to reward a body of work.
What the film is not
Paper Tiger is not a conventional 1970s-style crime film. Gray's references are older and more literary. The film is closer to a family tragedy than to a heist or a gangster picture, and the violence, when it comes, is brief rather than stylized.
It is not a star vehicle in the conventional sense either. Driver, Johansson and Teller are all well known, but the film gives them an ensemble, not a series of showcase scenes. The performances are restrained, and the film leaves room for silence.
Nor does it explain itself. Gray trusts the audience to follow the family dynamics without exposition. That confidence is part of what critics admire and part of what frustrates viewers who want a clearer plot. The mixed notices from Variety and some other outlets suggest the approach does not work for everyone.
Caveats
The scores are snapshots. Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic update as more reviews arrive, and the sample sizes differ. A film that opens at 85% can settle higher or lower once the wide release brings a second wave of notices.
The box office picture is incomplete. Paper Tiger opened in limited theaters, so its first-weekend gross will not be comparable to a wide release. The $15 million budget is Gray's own figure, and Neon has not published its marketing spend.
The awards picture is early. Gotham nominations are not wins, the Gijón result was pending on 13 November, and the Oscar race will not take shape until the critics' groups and the guilds vote.
What to watch
The first number is the wide-release box office on 20 November. A strong opening would confirm that the reviews and the cast can draw an adult audience. A weak one would suggest that the film's appeal is limited to critics and awards voters.
The second is the Gotham Awards on 30 November. A win for Best Feature or for Driver would give the film a headline and a boost before the critics' groups announce their picks.
The third is the critics' awards in December. Paper Tiger will compete with the year's festival titles, including the films that won at Cannes, Venice and Telluride. The early reviews put it in the conversation. The campaign will decide whether it stays there.
The fourth is the film's own reception outside the coasts. Platform releases often look strong in New York and Los Angeles and then fade when they expand. Paper Tiger's subject is specific, but its themes are not. Whether audiences in the rest of the country respond will determine whether Neon has a hit or a respectable limited run.
Tags
Frequently asked questions
- What is Paper Tiger about?
- Paper Tiger is a 1986 New York crime drama about two brothers who pursue a business opportunity and become entangled with the Russian mafia. Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller star.
- When does Paper Tiger open wide?
- It opened in limited U.S. theaters on 13 November 2026 and expands to a wide release on 20 November 2026.
- What are Paper Tiger's Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic scores?
- On 14 November 2026, Rotten Tomatoes showed 85% from 114 critics' reviews, with an average rating of 7.0 out of 10. Metacritic showed 81 from 32 critics.
- Is Paper Tiger an awards contender?
- It has Gotham Award nominations for Best Feature and for Adam Driver's supporting performance. It premiered in competition at Cannes and opened the New York Film Festival, but no major wins have been announced.








